In Finding the Raga, Amit Chaudhuri reflects on his experiences with the learning, practice and thinking of Khayal

In Finding the Raga, Amit Chaudhuri reflects on his experiences with the learning, practice and thinking of Khayal
Written by admin
In Finding the Raga, Amit Chaudhuri reflects on his experiences with the learning, practice and thinking of Khayal

Amit Chaudhuri’s e e book Discovering the Raga: An Improvisation on Indian Tune is a collection of essays with meandering autobiographical notes studded with poetic contemplations about Indian music, Khayal in ship.

Accounts of Chaudhuri’s scamper from Mumbai with its diversified soundscapes to the unnerving gentle of a London condominium (the place the horn sounded thrice sooner or later of his two years’ fill), scurry parallel with accounts of his speedy stints as Canadian music creator and Avadhi poet and ultimately discovering Khayal as “his mainstay”. The scamper is really useful with intense seriousness as he reflects on his experiences with the finding out, practice and thinking of Khayal whereas drawing from a convincing mannequin of literary worlds.

In these ruminations, Chaudhuri seems to be wish to be at issues anew — acquainted issues glow with a specific hue as when a ray of sunshine from an unanticipated route falls on a acquainted object.  As an alternative of argue, he poesies — that Khayal is modernist, that the main act of creation in Khayal alaap is evasion, that the enviornment of Bhakti is one with out tragedy….  And, he arrives at these through a crisscrossing of methods drawn from myriad worlds — Khayal lastly, Natyasastra, Hindi movie music, dance, movie, Tagore, Ray, Meera, Tulsi, Kalidasa, Bob Dylan, DH Lawrence and masses others.

In the splicing collectively of now not in level of reality worlds, these essays may maybe maybe presumably correctly be seen as capricious or indulgent. Nevertheless what poetry escapes eternally and from all people the value of being indulgent? Definitely, what artwork work is?

As an illustration, he writes with regard to the simultaneous presence and non-assertion of the tonic, the sa, in ascending phrases of the Raga Yaman — it is persistently ni re ga and now not ni sa re ga — “Yaman gives as important with evasion as with expression. In actuality, evasion, in an exposition, is a recurrent accomplish of expression.” Nevertheless isn’t this trustworthy of important else? Portray, current writing — what’s intentionally now not talked about is equally obligatory as what’s talked about. Nevertheless because it emerges in the e e book, it gives a 2nd of a fragile “aha”.

The subtitle — An Improvisation on Indian Tune — signifies that the e e book itself is an alaap.  There are not any chapter headings or numberings and the e e book flows almost seamlessly with current chapters starting quietly, with none announcement. On the honest-aspect pages is inscribed “Discovering the Raga” and on the left “Amit Chaudhuri”. In a flight of creativeness — now not in contrast to many we stumble upon in the e e book — one may maybe maybe liken these to the names of the raga and tala. A raga gives never-ending probabilities for music and the tala each constrains and organises it; and one may maybe maybe uncover the notion of Raga in a pair of methods nonetheless this ship exploration of a e e book is concurrently constrained and enabled by the life experiences and sensibilities of Amit Chaudhuri. This recommendation is a khayal, an notion born of creativeness, love important that the e e book gives.

The essays are autobiography, poetry, historic earlier, musicology flitting inside and out, drawing from each numerous. His essay on raga associations with time and seasons is poetic and righteous-looking out as are his reflections on the artistry of Ray. His accounts of his expertise of the soundscapes of the somewhat a few areas he lived — in Mumbai and London — are sexy, pensive reflections about what sounds round that you simply simply can moreover perform to your sensibilities.

And there are others which shall be now not so convincing.  Equal to his resolve on the thaats to distinction them with ragas. Whereas the contrasts are lovingly explored and we’ve now some righteous-looking out articulation proper right here, some remarks betray an absence of readability about what thaat as a musicological notion is. Chaudhuri goes through Bhatkhande’s ten thaats or guardian scales beneath which recognized ragas are categorized for the notes that occur in them. And that’s what the thaat machine is — one system of classification, now not, as Chaudhuri writes, an memoir of how ragas are derived. He takes enviornment with Bhatkhande who “signifies that Malkauns derives from Bhairavi thaat” arguing that it seems to be wish to be unsure {that a} minor pentatonic, discovered internationally, developed from a seven-show conceal melody. Traditionally and aesthetically, the thaat machine is a instrument of classification, now not a tool of basis of ragas. The identical confusion underlies his reveal that pentatonic scales too may maybe maybe moreover aloof comprise guardian scales since a few of the “oldest melodies recognized to man” are definitely pentatonic — love “Durga, Megh, Dhani.”

Quite a few bumps in the expertise of the e e book are careless remarks love “alaap” method introduction now not ideally worthwhile in Bangla nonetheless “presumably in all north Indian languages” — undoubtedly it was now not so arduous to look at this out!

In Finding the Raga Amit Chaudhuri reflects on his experiences with the learning practice and thinking of Khayal

The essay on shruti or microtones conflates it with gamaka, a generic time interval for ornamentation together with the all-important meend or glissando.  After a barely arbitrary reveal that in the music “Construct-Re-Mi” Julie Andrews calls Ti, the final present conceal, ‘a drink with jam and bread’, as a result of it is “a makeshift meal previous to dinner at day’s finish”, Chaudhuri observes that the present conceal Ti or the swara ni engenders a converse of incompleteness. “Shruti has to protect out with the present conceal’s anticipation of the subsequent present conceal and its refusal to be straight reworked into it. It’s a … converse of turning into”.  To light up his ideas on shruti, Chaudhuri quotes Cavafy’s Ithaka about “getting there”.

“Succor Ithaka persistently on your ideas …. Nevertheless don’t urge the scamper the least bit.”

Right here is now not shruti nonetheless the notion of gamaka which has really been described as a result of the shadow of 1 present conceal in another: “The confluence of two notes may maybe maybe moreover aloof be love the confluence of shade and photo voltaic” — so goes an mild textual inform materials about gamaka. Shrutis aren’t lit up with the exception of through gamakas nonetheless the two are numerous ideas and musical entities.

If there is a centre to the e e book, it is his argument that Khayal is modernist.  He argues that the fact that Khayal performers regularly good the phlegm from their throats sooner or later of effectivity signifies that it is task artwork work — which is modernist! Right here is at easiest a stretch!

Nevertheless the extra vital argument is from his resolve that “modernist method destruction of recognisability” and his exposition of the dismantling of the composition as a recognisable entity in Khayal considerably after Abdul Wahid Khan and Amir Khan.

Chaudhuri claims that by reducing the saunter of the composition to a extraordinarily slack vilambit time cycle and “frequent indifference to the meanings of the phrases” these two masters initiated the “dismantling of the recognisability of the composition”.  Whereas one is of the identical opinion that Khayal has struck its have route in engagement with tala and the composition, Amir Khan’s is now not the ideally worthwhile method. “Modernism” may even be affected in numerous methods too as in the music of Kumar Gandharva who too engaged with the bandish in a radically current method nonetheless was now not detached to the that method of the phrases of the compositions and who had no make the most of for the ati vilambit laya of Amir Khan. Although, when Chaudhuri says “Modernism … has religious timbre that arises now not from that method, nonetheless from sound,” that is equally acceptable to Kumarji’s music.

In these essays Chaudhuri very important has one mannequin of Khayal in ideas and does a disservice to the multitudinous worlds of Khayal by extrapolating from this one mannequin to the complete universe of Khayal.

What moreover strikes me is the profound absence of the South in his scamper. Specific, there are a few tutorial remarks about Carnatic music to distinction Khayal with, nonetheless there is no longer any memoir of an expertise of Carnatic music in the mannequin he recounts his expertise of Beethoven or of Julie Andrews in My Colourful Woman. Or of the leisure Southern for that matter.

Beethoven was fragment of his folks’ knowledge collection and he listens to the symphonies as a boy, nonetheless even the older Chaudhuri has now not let in any music from the South. He knowledge no stumble upon with the brilliance of a Mali or a Rajaratnam Pillai, the uncontainable creativity of a GNB or the sinuous tunefulness of a T Brinda.

Writing about his mom’s recede to sooner or later of his fill in London he writes: “My mom…studied Boy George and his cohort — we on a customary foundation watched TV collectively — now not with animosity or stoicism nonetheless with a sweet suspension of disbelief.” Carnatic music would not acquire even this engagement.

Meera, Tulasi, Bob Dylan, Tagore and Ray time and once more, Wordsworth, Yeats, Turner and Monet, Khusro, Amir Khan, Kishori Amonkar, numerous Khayaliyas, and masses others rub shoulders in Chaudhuri’s languid explorations. Nothing Southern — Andal, Bharatiyar, Akka Mahadevi, Tyagaraja, Vallathol, Girish Karnad even — seems to be wish to be to have touched him and long-established his expertise in any method. I salvage a lone Raghava Menon quoted in the dialogue of the raga time affiliation. Fairly wonderful! To be trustworthy to Chaudhuri, it is now not extraordinary for a northerner to steadfastly ignore the South.

The e e book gives an uneven expertise — moments of enjoyment are many, nonetheless sprinkled amongst these are these of bewilderment and dissatisfaction.

Dr Lakshmi Sreeram is a Carnatic and Hindustani musician. Write to her at [email protected]

About the author