The account of Carmen Winstead is false. Beginning in 2006, this urban legend proliferated on social media platforms as a chain letter. According to the narrative, there is no record of a girl named Carmen Winstead being forced into a sewer drain.
According to the tale of Carmen Winstead, anyone who did not advance the tale would be murdered by Carmen’s ghost. In the story, five girls force Carmen into a sewer drain, breaking her neck in the process. According to the girls, she fell. The identical narrative was also told with Jessica Smith as the protagonist instead of Carmen Winstead.